Before you read

Build the holiday around what people really want to eat.

Thanksgiving in Hawaii does not need to imitate a mainland dining room. CurtisJ's take is to keep the table generous, local, and practical, with enough familiar holiday structure that nobody feels lost and enough island food that the meal still belongs here.

Thanksgiving in Hawaii doesn’t look like Thanksgiving on the mainland. There might be a turkey somewhere on the table, but it’s sharing space with kalua pig, mac salad, lomi salmon, and a dozen other dishes that reflect the island’s multicultural food traditions. It’s less Norman Rockwell and more backyard luau — which, honestly, is a significant upgrade.

This guide gives you a complete Hawaiian Thanksgiving menu, from the proteins to the sides to the desserts, with timeline and prep tips to make it all come together without losing your mind.

The Hawaiian Thanksgiving Table

A Hawaiian Thanksgiving is generous, multicultural, and abundant. Most families serve a mix of mainland Thanksgiving classics and Hawaiian favorites. Here’s how the table typically breaks down.

The Proteins

Kalua Turkey (or Kalua Pig)

Many Hawaiian families skip the traditional roasted turkey entirely and go with kalua pig as the centerpiece. But some families split the difference: a whole turkey rubbed with Hawaiian salt and liquid smoke, wrapped in ti leaves (or foil), and slow-roasted until it falls off the bone — kalua-style turkey. The smoky, salty flavors work beautifully with turkey.

If you’re going the kalua pig route, start it the night before or early morning — it needs 8-12 hours of low, slow cooking.

Huli Huli Chicken

If the weather cooperates (and in Hawaii, it usually does), huli huli chicken on the grill is a Thanksgiving crowd-pleaser. The sweet, sticky glaze and charcoal smoke are irresistible, and grilling frees up your oven for everything else.

Shoyu Chicken

For a no-stress protein that feeds a crowd, braised shoyu chicken is hard to beat. It cooks in one pot, can be made the day before (and it’s better for it), and the sauce over rice is Thanksgiving-worthy.

The Sides

Hawaiian Macaroni Salad

Mandatory. Make a double batch the day before Thanksgiving. It’s the one dish that disappears fastest and causes the most complaints when it runs out.

Lomilomi Salmon

Cold, bright, and refreshing against all the heavy, warm dishes. Make it the morning of Thanksgiving — it only needs a few hours to meld.

Two Scoops Rice

Yes, there’s rice at Hawaiian Thanksgiving. Always. Use your rice cooker and cook it right. Make extra — you’ll need it.

Sweet Potatoes (Hawaiian Style)

Skip the marshmallow-topped casserole. Hawaiian-style sweet potatoes are simpler: roasted Okinawan purple sweet potatoes or regular sweet potatoes with butter and Hawaiian sea salt. The purple sweet potatoes are stunning on the table and naturally sweet enough without added sugar.

Chicken Long Rice

A warm, gingery noodle soup on the Thanksgiving table might seem unusual if you’re not from Hawaii, but it’s a luau table staple and provides a lighter counterpoint to all the rich dishes.

Cranberry Sauce

Even Hawaiian Thanksgiving keeps some mainland traditions. But many families make theirs with lilikoi (passion fruit) or pineapple juice for a tropical twist.

Stuffing / Dressing

Hawaiian-style stuffing often incorporates Portuguese sweet bread (or Hawaiian rolls if you can’t find it), Portuguese sausage, celery, and sage. The sweetness of the bread balances the savory sausage beautifully.

The Desserts

Haupia

Silky coconut pudding cut into squares. The essential Hawaiian dessert at any gathering — light enough to eat after a massive meal, and always the first thing to disappear.

Haupia Pie or Chocolate Haupia Pie

The show-stopping Hawaiian Thanksgiving dessert. A chocolate pudding layer topped with haupia in a macadamia nut or graham cracker crust. Ted’s Bakery on the North Shore made this famous, and it’s become the Hawaiian Thanksgiving pie.

Sweet Potato Pie

Made with Okinawan purple sweet potatoes for a gorgeous purple filling, or regular sweet potatoes for the classic. Either way, it’s a bridge between mainland Thanksgiving tradition and Hawaiian flavors.

Pumpkin Crunch (Local Style)

A Hawaiian potluck classic — pumpkin filling topped with a crunchy butter-cake mix and macadamia nut topping. Easier than pumpkin pie and feeds a crowd.

The Timeline

2-3 Days Before

  • Make mac salad (it needs overnight minimum)
  • Buy all ingredients — check the pantry guide for your shopping list
  • Make haupia (it needs 3+ hours to set)

Day Before

  • Prep kalua pig or turkey (season and wrap)
  • Make shoyu chicken if using (better the next day)
  • Make pie(s)
  • Prep lomi salmon (salt the salmon if using fresh)

Thanksgiving Morning

  • Start kalua pig/turkey in the oven (early — it needs 8+ hours)
  • Make lomi salmon
  • Start rice cooker
  • Roast sweet potatoes
  • Make chicken long rice

2 Hours Before

  • Fire up the grill for huli huli chicken if using
  • Set out mac salad, lomi salmon, and haupia
  • Thin out mac salad with a splash of milk
  • Make any last-minute sides

Feeding a Crowd

Hawaiian Thanksgiving is generous by nature. Plan for more than you think you need — leftovers are part of the tradition. For 12-15 people:

  • 8-10 lb pork butt for kalua pig (or a 12-14 lb turkey)
  • Double batch of mac salad
  • Triple batch of rice
  • Full batch of lomi salmon
  • 2 pans of haupia
  • 1 chocolate haupia pie + 1 sweet potato pie

For more party planning advice, see How to Throw a Hawaiian Backyard Party.

Explore More